Caltech professor stops grading homework as everyone uses AI
| Source: HN | Original article
A Caltech professor has stopped grading homework for accuracy, opting to assess only completion as AI tools make verification difficult.
Caltech mathematics professor Yi Ni has stopped grading homework for accuracy, opting instead to award points simply for completion. Ni, who has taught low‑dimensional geometry and topology at the institute for 17 years, told Business Insider on Nov 16 2026 that the rise of generative‑AI chatbots makes it impossible to verify whether a student’s solution is their own work. “Students are using AI to produce answers on typical problem sets,” he said, prompting a shift to a completion‑based rubric while keeping proctored exams as the primary competence gate.
The move underscores a growing dilemma for elite STEM schools: traditional homework, once a reliable gauge of problem‑solving skill, is losing its diagnostic value in an era where AI can generate correct solutions instantly. By grading only for effort, Ni aims to preserve the habit of regular practice without penalising students for tools that are now ubiquitous. The change also signals a broader reassessment of assessment design, as faculty grapple with how to maintain academic integrity when detection of AI‑generated work is unreliable.
Observers will watch how other departments at Caltech and peer institutions respond. Potential next steps include the development of AI‑aware assignment formats, increased reliance on in‑person examinations, or the adoption of new plagiarism‑detection technologies tailored to generative models. The conversation is already spilling into university policy circles, where administrators are weighing the balance between encouraging innovative tool use and preserving rigorous, verifiable evaluation of student learning.
Sources
Back to AIPULSEN